Alan Waldman :
TELEVISION | Brit detectives solve murders on Caribbean island in ‘Death in Paradise’

Ben Miller, Kris Marshall, and Ardol O’Hanlon change out as top cops in excellent tropical killer series.

By Alan Waldman | The Rag Blog | April 8, 2018

[In his Rag Blog column, Alan Waldman reviews some of his favorite films and TV series that readers may have missed, including TV dramas, mysteries, and comedies from Canada, England, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand and Scotland. Most are available on DVD, Netflix and/or Netflix Instant Streaming, and some episodes are on YouTube.]

For the past eight years a nice little murder mystery series, Death in Paradise, has been piling up corpses on a fictional Caribbean island. So far 56 episodes (seven seasons) have unspooled on the exotic French tropical isle of St. Marie, filmed on Guadeloupe. The series began airing in 2011 with Ben Miles as the British chief detective. In Season 4 he was replaced by lanky Kris Marshall and then again in Season 6 by Irish comic Ardal O’Hanlon (playing it straight).

The first four seasons are available on Netflix Instant streaming. The first seven are on YouTube — some for free and some for a fee. This one is gratis.

These are cozy mysteries, where at the end the detective gathers all the suspects and then unmasks the killer. This is a British-French crime drama created by Robert Thorogood and featuring a fun Anglo-French cast playing island cops. It has consistently enjoyed high ratings. Season 4 (2015) averaged 9.03 million viewers. Each episode was among the top three most-watched programs of the day in the U.K. and in the top 10 most-watched programs of the week. An eighth season has been ordered, with O’Hanlon returning. The series airs in France, Canada and Australia.

British detective Richard Poole (Ben Miller, whose 70 credits include Paddington 2, Johnny English, and The Armstrong and Miller Show) is assigned to investigate the murder of a British police officer on the fictional French Caribbean island of Saint Marie. After he successfully finds the murderer, he is reluctantly required by his supervisors to replace the victim and stay on as the detective inspector of the island, solving new cases as they appear, and being the butt of many fish-out-of-water jokes.

At the start of Series 3, Poole is killed and London detective Humphrey Goodman (Kris Marshall; 42 credits including Murder City, Love Actually, and Death at a Funeral) arrives to investigate the death of his strait-laced predecessor. He then stays in the job as chief investigator on the island. In the second half of Series 6, he resigns so he can stay in London with his new girlfriend, and his replacement is DI Jack Mooney, played by Ardal O’Hanlon (brilliant in Father Ted, My Hero, and 26 other films and series).

Saint Marie is a British Overseas Territory, but about 30% of its people are French, due to previous history, with the language still widely spoken. The backstory appears to be a blend of two real islands near to Guadeloupe, with size and location aligning with Marie-Galante and history and language aligning with Dominica.

An executive producer is legendary scribe Tony Jordan (Life on Mars, Hustle, Eastenders, The Graham Norton Show). The island’s police commissioner is played by megatalented Don Warrington (Rising Damp, New City Law, Manchild, and 72 more credits).

The cast also includes Danny John-Jules (Blade II, Little Shop of Horrors, and Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels), Elizabeth Bourgine (71 mostly French credits), Sara Martins (59 credits, largely French) and Joséphine Jobert. Guest suspects have included James Fox, Tara Fitzgerald, James Wilby, Simon Callow, Helen Baxendale, Frances Barber, Sharon Small, Nicholas Farrell, Honeysuckle Weeks, Rupert Graves, Colin Salmon, Gemma Jones, Denis Lawson, Joe Absolom, Jill Halfpenny, Neil Morrissey, Robert Pugh, and hundreds more fine British thesps.

The series earned thumbs up from more than 94.1% of 9,239 imdb viewers. It was big with all demos, especially females 30 and older and 18 and younger.

Victims include a nun, a rock musician, two treasure hunters, a cosmetician, a horror movie actress, a gigolo, several tourists, a stewardess, a surf instructor, a volleyball star, the outgoing island governor, a chef, and dozens more.

Normally, each episode ends with a comedic scene or a celebratory trip by the police force to Catherine’s bar. The final episode of most series has included a subplot wherein the lead DI is tempted to return to the UK by the prospect of a job offer or personal relationship, but in the end, he decides to remain on the island.

Death in Paradise has remained one of the U.K.’s top three series. The Caribbean locales are delightful, the cast is fun and the mysteries are entertaining. We usually fail to guess the murderer.

Alan Waldman has updated 89 of his Rag Blog columns with recent information and current free links in his new paperback/Kindle book 89 Smart, Foreign TV Series: English-language Comedies, Thrillers & Dramas from the U.K., Canada, Australia, Ireland, N.Z., Scotland & Europe (+362 Favorite 1997-2016 Films for Grown-Ups). Rag Bloggers have never seen his descriptions of 255 great 1997-2011 films in the book. Find it at

[Oregon writer and Houston native Alan Waldman holds a B.A. in theater arts from Brandeis University and has worked as an editor at The Hollywood Reporter and Honolulu magazine. Read 95 more of Alan Waldman’s articles on The Rag Blog.]

This entry was posted in RagBlog and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *