
Honk for Trump Vance. Photo by Thomas Hawk / Flickr/ Creative Commons.
By Michael Meeropol / The Rag Blog / September 16, 2025
The following is an expanded version of a commentary delivered by Michael Meeropol, Professor Emeritus of Economics at Western New England University over WAMC-FM on August 29, 2025. It has been adapted for The Rag Blog. Michael Meeropol will be Thorne Dreyer’s guest on Rag Radio, Friday, September 19, 2-3 p.m., on KOOP 91.7-FM in Austin and streamed at KOOP.org.
On Monday, August 11, I joined elected officials, activists, and ordinary citizens at a rally
in Peekskill, NY in Westchester County. We were there to support an Ecuadorean immigrant, Amy Lituma, who had been offered a Hobson’s Choice by ICE — either self-deport and you can take your child with you or we will arrest you and you will be separated from your child while your case is being adjudicated.
This is not an exaggeration. At the rally Attorney Ignacio Acevedo, from the New York Civil Liberties Union, described a case of a mother who was separated from her one-year-old. The baby is in Newburgh, NY in Orange County — the mother is incarcerated in Louisiana.
[See “ ‘When You Take the Mom Away, You Take the Whole Family Away’: Peekskill Rally Condemns ICE Tactics,” The Examiner News, August 12, 2025, available at
https://www.theexaminernews.com/when-you-take-the-mom-away-you-take-the-whole-family-
away-peekskill-rally-condemns-ice-tactics/]
I’d like to skip over the fact that virtually everything the Trump Administration has done
to ramp up deportations has been illegal (though I fear the runaway Supreme Court will make them legal after the fact). Trump and his minions do not care if what they are doing is illegal — they believe they have the power to ignore the law because the 6-3 right-wing majority on the Supreme Court has already given Trump a “get out of jail free” card. Also, many Trump supporters don’t care if what ICE is doing is illegal because they are so convinced that these immigrants are poisoning the blood stream of our country that anything done to get rid of them is all right with them. (Please note – I said many – I didn’t even say a majority because in fact I do not know how deep the fascist belief system has penetrated our population.)
No – I would like to ask and answer the rhetorical question — How does the self-deportation of this mother and her four-year-old son help American citizens and green card holders? To do this, I want to go back to a Rag Blog contribution from four weeks ago which constituted a deep dive into a speech given by Vice President Vance.
(What follows does include a quote from the previous Rag Blog contribution, but the issue explored is a different one from a few weeks ago.)
In that speech he said the following:
“[D]eporting low-wage immigrants will raise the wages of the native-born… [That
would] create higher living standards for those who are born and raised here, whether they’re black, white, or any other skin color. Every Western society, as I stand here today, has significant demographic and cultural problems. There is something about Western liberalism that seems almost suicidal, or at least socially parasitic, that tends to feed off of a healthy host until there’s nothing left. That’s why the demographic trends across the West are so bad… America in ’25 is more diverse than it has ever been. And yet, the institutions that take this incredibly diverse country and form culture are weaker than they have ever been. While our elites tell us that diversity is our greatest strength, they destroy the very institutions that allow us to thrive and build a common sense of purpose and meaning as Americans.
“… Social bonds form among people who have something in common. They share the same neighborhood. They share the same church. They send their kids to the same school. And what we’re doing is recognizing that if you stop importing millions of foreigners into the country, you allow that social cohesion to form naturally. It’s hard to become neighbors with your fellow citizens when your own government keeps on importing new neighbors every single year at a record number.”
Notice that Vance doesn’t dare raise the canard that the Trump Administration is deporting “the worst of the worst” as in violent criminals. That claim may be believed by some but it is a bold-faced lie. According to the Marshall Project:
“People with no criminal convictions at all make up two-thirds of the more than 120,000 people deported between January and May. For another 8%, the only offense on their record was illegal entry to the U.S. Only about 12% were convicted of a crime that was either violent or potentially violent.”
[See: “Ice is Deporting Thousands with Minor Offenses — From Traffic Violations to Weed Possession. Many people with little or no criminal record have been swept into the administration’s immigration dragnet since January, an analysis of deportation data shows.”
(August 15, 2025) available at: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2025/08/15/ice-georgia-
traffic-stop-arrest-immigration.]
Videos are circulating from New York court houses and from street arrests, showing ICE Agents forcibly separating parents from children, breaking car windows and arresting ordinary workers, grabbing a man who had just dropped his kids off at school. I saw these three separate videos during just one evening watching TV news.
The good news is, bystanders are filming these outrageous events with their cell phones and community members are yelling at the ICE Nazis to go home. Demanding to know their names, attempting to photograph them, though most of them are hiding their faces. In a world where justice prevails, these ICE Nazis will someday have to answer for their “work” in courts of law.
And people wrongfully deported are fighting back with the help of courageous lawyers who are not kissing Trump’s behind. Kilmar Obrego Garcia, the man wrongfully deported to a gulag in El Salvador and then arrested when the Trump Administration finally complied with a judge’s order to bring him back to the U.S. (the charge was basically that he drove some undocumented people in his car!) was ordered freed by a Maryland Judge. After a day at home with his family (during which time he took the offensive and sued the government for his unlawful deportation, the government has arrested him again. They offered him a choice of pleading guilty and being sent to Costa Rica or, if he refused to plead guilty, they threatened to send him to Uganda! As of now, a federal judge has ordered the Trump Administration not to deport him till at least
October. Unfortunately, he remains in ICE custody, while members of the Trump
Administration, without any evidence, claim he is a member of a Salvadoran gang called MS-13. This prompted his lawyers to ask a federal judge for a gag order on Trump and members of his administration.































CARL DAVIDSON / COMMENTARY / Trump as big-city crimefighter?
Cartoon courtesy of LeftLinks.
By Carl Davidson / The Rag Blog / August 15, 2025
This article was originally posted on August 15, 2025, as a weekly editorial on LeftLinks by its editor Carl Davidson and is cross-posted to The Rag Blog.
Whenever I hear politicians, especially those like President Donald Trump and his MAGA wannabes, talk about “war on crime” and “letting the police do their job,” my muscles tighten and fists clench. I’m ready to rumble. They have no idea what they’re talking about, save for dead ends that would make matters worse. In a fair debate, I would mop the floor with them.
I’ll start with a short story. I was chatting with a Beaver County DA a few years back, he was an FDR liberal of sorts, who has since passed on. I asked him one day if he saw a connection between the unemployment rate and the arrest rate here locally. He laughed softly and said he kept two charts on his office wall, with the numbers of each, which he updated regularly. “What did they show?” I asked. ‘They match exactly,” he replied, “But too many lack the will or the ideas to do anything about it.”
My lawyer friend had a point. First, we need the will to name and confront the problem as it’s perceived by those who live it. Using statistics of positive change starts on the wrong foot. Second, we need ideas about what to do, and we need to dump some bad ideas along the way.
Which leads to another story. For five years, I worked in a Chicago jobs program I had designed for “at-risk” youth — computer repair and network installation. I ran it successfully in five tough Chicago public high schools. The principals gave me a big room, and I brought boxes of screwdrivers and truckloads of donated older computers. I told the kids:
“You can’t steal anything here. You wouldn’t know what to do with it anyway. But if you can get one of these computers to work, it’s yours. You can take it home with you. And I’ll teach you how to do it, and more. The most crucial product in this class is going to be what’s between your ears, the skills you gain. Computers that work and good spare parts are just byproducts.”
It was a solid success, and one special group heard about it and approached me separately. They were all ex-offenders, recently out of prison. “If we found the space and some funds, could you do this for us, for ex-offenders and some inmates on work release?” I agreed and worked with them for five years, too.
We talked about everything during the classes. 0ne day I dropped the phrase, “Lock ‘em up and throw away the key.” One guy smiled and said, “They don’t get it, not at all.” “What do you mean,” I asked? “Nearly everyone you put in jail will come out some day. It may be five years, seven, or whatever. But nearly all of us come back out. They give us a new suit of clothes, a state I.D. card, a bus ticket to wherever ‘home’ is, and $50. Now think about it. I’m back in the ‘hood’ with less than $50 to buy food. What am I going to do in order to survive?”
“But here’s the next question,” he continued. “What if I were an 18-year-old kid who highjacked a car and got caught, and was sentenced to five years? The reality of most prisons is harsh and stark. This young kid will get nothing in the way of what you’re doing here. First, he’ll be brutalized and hardened. Then he’ll join a prison gang for defense.”
“So he will also learn new skills on how to be a better criminal. Then he gets dumped on the street with his bus ticket. Hardly anyone will hire him for a regular job. Some of his family won’t want to deal with him, either. So he hooks up with the “outside” version of the gang he had joined in prison, and he’ll start at the bottom, finding a corner to sell drugs on the street.
War on crime? In prison, we don’t fight crime. We create schools and conditions to create more and better criminals.
That’s why we laugh at “throwing away the key.” Unless you’re a mass murderer, that key is going to let you out as a new and better criminal in a few years. They want to get tougher, more brutal? They can do that. But what does it produce? A tougher and more brutal criminal.
Not all prisons are simply bleak. Some have decent libraries, where you can study to be a jailhouse lawyer or a Muslim, a Buddhist, or a Christian minister. (I know one guy who did all four). In maintaining the physical plant and structure of the prison itself — a much-desired prison job — some will learn carpentry, sheet metal, and plumbing skills.
Continue reading →